Rosanne AustinDiscovery Hub
Interview

Busting Myths About High Risk Pregnancy with Dr. Stu Fischbein, MD #highriskpregnancy

Fertility mindset coach Rosanne Austin interviews Dr. Stuart Fischbein to debunk myths about high-risk pregnancy labels and empower women with evidence-based information about natural birth.

Teachings 6

  • The term 'high risk pregnancy' has no medical definition and is often used as a fear tactic rather than meaningful medical information

    Dr. Stuart Fischbein explains that ACOG considers pregnancy itself to be high-risk, meaning virtually every pregnant woman gets labeled as high-risk for arbitrary reasons like being over 35, having twins, or previous IVF

  • VBAC carries only a 1 in 1,200 risk of serious complications—the same risk as Down syndrome at age 25, yet no one calls 25-year-olds high-risk

    Dr. Fischbein breaks down the actual mathematics: 1 in 200 risk of uterine separation times 16% risk of bad outcome equals 1 in 1,200 actual risk

  • Constant fear and stress during pregnancy bathes the developing baby in cortisol and adrenaline instead of beneficial hormones like oxytocin

    Dr. Fischbein explains how fear-based prenatal care creates chronic stress that affects fetal development through stress hormone exposure

  • Midwifery care with 30-60 minute visits produces better outcomes than 6-8 minute OB visits, including lower rates of gestational diabetes and hypertension

    Dr. Fischbein compares outcomes between midwifery model of care focused on prevention versus medicalized model focused on problem management

  • The Friedman curve used to justify labor interventions is fundamentally flawed because it labels 50% of women as dilating 'too slowly' by mathematical design

    Dr. Fischbein explains that the curve represents an average, meaning half of all women naturally fall below it—making normal variation appear pathological

  • Women must question medical interventions and demand evidence-based reasoning rather than accepting fear-based recommendations

    Austin and Dr. Fischbein emphasize that patients have the right to challenge unnecessary procedures like routine color Doppler ultrasounds and excessive monitoring

Quotable Moments 4

  • High risk is something that makes your obstetrician uncomfortable. Period.

    Dr. Stuart Fischbein
  • The design is perfect. Doesn't always work, but the design is perfect.

    Dr. Stuart Fischbein
  • Whatever brought this baby to me is gonna see it through. Like, I just refused to take those labels on.

    Rosanne Austin
  • You can't make an informed decision if you're not given honest information.

    Dr. Stuart Fischbein

Questions This Video Answers

What does high-risk pregnancy actually mean medically?

High risk is something that makes your obstetrician uncomfortable. Period.

Dr. Stuart Fischbein

High-risk pregnancy has no official medical definition and often means nothing more than what makes your doctor uncomfortable. True high-risk conditions like placenta previa require intervention, but being over 35 or having twins doesn't automatically make you high-risk.

How safe is VBAC compared to repeat cesarean?

The actual risk of any woman going into, deciding to have a VBAC after a single low transverse cesarean of having a ruptured uterus leading to a really bad outcome is one in six times one in two hundred or one in twelve hundred.

Dr. Stuart Fischbein

VBAC has only a 1 in 1,200 risk of serious complications—equivalent to Down syndrome risk at age 25. This is significantly safer than multiple repeat cesareans, which carry cumulative risks including placenta accreta and hysterectomy.

Should I avoid home birth if I'm over 35 or having twins?

Just because you're over thirty five does not make you high risk. Just because you have a high BMI does not make you high risk.

Dr. Stuart Fischbein

Age over 35 or twins alone don't make you high-risk until actual complications develop. Home birth can be safe for healthy women with proper screening, regardless of age. Even some twin pregnancies can be safely managed at home with experienced providers.

How does fear during pregnancy affect my baby?

All this time, the woman is growing a baby inside of her, constantly bathing the baby in the stress hormones of cortisol and adrenaline, and not the dopamine and oxytocin that they should be bathing their babies in

Dr. Stuart Fischbein

Chronic fear and stress during pregnancy expose your developing baby to cortisol and adrenaline instead of beneficial hormones like oxytocin. This stress hormone environment can impact fetal brain development and overall health.

Watch on YouTube

Key Points 6

The term 'high risk pregnancy' has no medical definition and is often used as a fear tactic rather than meaningful medical information

VBAC carries only a 1 in 1,200 risk of serious complications—the same risk as Down syndrome at age 25, yet no one calls 25-year-olds high-risk

Constant fear and stress during pregnancy bathes the developing baby in cortisol and adrenaline instead of beneficial hormones like oxytocin

Midwifery care with 30-60 minute visits produces better outcomes than 6-8 minute OB visits, including lower rates of gestational diabetes and hypertension

The Friedman curve used to justify labor interventions is fundamentally flawed because it labels 50% of women as dilating 'too slowly' by mathematical design

Women must question medical interventions and demand evidence-based reasoning rather than accepting fear-based recommendations